What to Say When a Headhunter Calls: How to Nail the First Conversation

For many job seekers, receiving a call from a headhunter can be both exciting and nerve-wracking. It’s an opportunity to explore new career options, but it can also feel overwhelming if you’re unsure how to handle the conversation. Unlike a direct job application, where you control the timing and details, a recruiter call can catch you off guard. Many candidates struggle with what to say, how to present themselves effectively, and how to make the most of the opportunity.

A well-prepared response to a recruiter call can make all the difference in whether you move forward in the hiring process. This initial conversation is your chance to showcase your strengths, express your career aspirations, and determine if the opportunity aligns with your goals. It’s also an excellent chance to build a relationship with a recruiter who can keep you in mind for future positions that match your skills and ambitions.

This guide will provide you with expert tips on how to handle a headhunter call with confidence and professionalism. You’ll learn how to make a strong first impression, position yourself as a top candidate, and navigate the conversation strategically to increase your chances of securing your next great job opportunity.

What Recruiters Look for in That First Chat

The first conversation with a headhunter is crucial. They use this call to assess whether you’re a good fit for the role and to determine if you should be presented to their client. Here’s what recruiters typically look for:

• Professionalism and Communication Skills: Headhunters need to know you can articulate your experience clearly and confidently. Speak concisely and avoid rambling. Your ability to communicate effectively reflects how you will interact with hiring managers and potential employers.
• Relevant Experience: They will ask about your past roles, key responsibilities, and major accomplishments to see if you align with the job opening. Be prepared to highlight how your experience directly applies to the role they are presenting.
• Career Goals and Motivations: Recruiters want to understand what you’re looking for in your next role—whether it’s higher pay, career growth, a better work-life balance, or a new challenge. Being clear about your career goals helps them match you with the right opportunities.
• Availability and Flexibility: They need to know your timeline for making a move and if you have any restrictions, such as non-compete agreements or relocation limitations. If you’re currently employed, let them know when you’d realistically be able to start a new role.
• Cultural Fit: Many recruiters assess your personality and work style to ensure you align with their client’s company culture. They may ask about your preferred work environment, team collaboration style, or how you handle challenges.
• Salary Expectations: While you don’t need to give an exact number right away, having a salary range in mind will help the recruiter determine if the opportunity is a fit. Research salary benchmarks in your industry to ensure your expectations are realistic.
• Openness to Opportunities: Even if the current role isn’t ideal, expressing interest in future opportunities helps keep you on their radar for other positions. Maintaining a positive and open attitude can lead to future career advancements.

How to Position Yourself as a Strong Candidate

Your goal in the first conversation is to present yourself as a high-value candidate while ensuring the opportunity aligns with your career goals. Here’s how to do it:

• Research the Recruiter and Company (if known): If you were contacted via email or LinkedIn, take a moment to review the recruiter’s profile and the company they’re hiring for. This helps you tailor your responses and demonstrate genuine interest.
• Prepare a Strong Elevator Pitch: Have a concise summary of your experience, key strengths, and what you’re looking for in your next role. Example: “I’m a digital marketing professional with seven years of experience in SEO and content strategy. I’ve led successful campaigns that increased organic traffic by 150% for my company. I’m now looking for a leadership role in a growth-focused organization where I can drive digital strategy and mentor a team.”
• Highlight Key Achievements: Instead of just listing responsibilities, mention specific achievements and how they’ve impacted your previous employers. Use metrics when possible to make your impact tangible.
• Express Enthusiasm and Openness: Even if the role isn’t perfect, showing enthusiasm makes a great impression. If the opportunity doesn’t fit, ask if they have other roles that might be a better match. A recruiter who sees you as adaptable and motivated is more likely to think of you for future positions.
• Be Honest but Strategic: If you’re not currently looking but may be in the future, let them know your timeline and the types of opportunities that would interest you. Recruiters appreciate candidates who are upfront about their career plans.
• Ask Thoughtful Questions: Engage in the conversation by asking about the role’s responsibilities, team structure, or company culture. This demonstrates genuine interest and can help you determine whether the opportunity is a good fit.

Common Recruiter Questions and How to Answer Them

Recruiters often ask a standard set of questions to gauge your suitability for a role. Here’s how to handle them:

1. “Tell me about yourself.”
   • Keep it concise and relevant. Focus on your experience, key skills, and what you’re looking for in your next role. Structure your response to highlight your most recent and relevant experience first.
2. “What are your salary expectations?”
   • Instead of stating an exact number, give a range based on market research. Example: “Based on my experience and market trends, I’m looking for something in the $80,000–$95,000 range, but I’m open to discussion based on the total compensation package.”
3. “Why are you looking for a new job?”
   • Stay positive and professional. Avoid badmouthing your current employer. Example: “I’m looking for a role that offers more growth opportunities and aligns with my long-term career goals.”
4. “What kind of work environment do you thrive in?”
   • Tailor your response to the company’s culture. If unsure, mention adaptability. Example: “I do well in collaborative environments where I can contribute ideas and work with cross-functional teams.”
5. “Are you interviewing with other companies?”
   • It’s okay to acknowledge other opportunities, but don’t overstate. Example: “I’m exploring a few opportunities that align with my career goals, but I’m particularly interested in roles that offer X and Y.”

How to Follow Up Without Being Annoying

Following up after a recruiter call is essential, but timing and approach matter. Here’s how to do it effectively:

• Send a Thank You Email: Within 24 hours, send a short, professional email thanking the recruiter for their time and reiterating your interest.
• Follow Up Strategically: If you haven’t heard back within a week, send a polite follow-up email asking for an update.
• Stay Connected on LinkedIn: If you had a good conversation, connect with the recruiter on LinkedIn and engage with their posts occasionally.
• Don’t Overwhelm Them: Avoid sending multiple follow-up emails in a short period. If they don’t respond, move on and keep them in mind for future opportunities.

Conclusion

Handling a headhunter call effectively can open doors to exciting career opportunities. By mastering the recruiter call, you can take control of your job search and unlock valuable career prospects. Stay prepared, stay confident, and make every conversation count!

---

In today’s competitive job market, many job seekers rely on online job boards and company career pages to find opportunities. However, a significant portion of job openings are never advertised publicly. This so-called “hidden job market” is where recruitment firms and headhunters play a crucial role in connecting top talent with exclusive opportunities.

Find the best local headhunters and recruiters for your search right here!

Simple….Easy…and yes Free!

To date HeadhuntersDirectory has assisted literally millions of jobseekers in the USA, Canada, the UK, Australia and many other locations. Connect with a local recruiting firm during your search for the next career opportunity, or search for the best talent for that vacancy!

The job seekers have been both local and from afar! The jobseekers have been across the entire spectrum from general laborer, to the C suite executive.